Don’t Wait Until You Need It: Why Every Piper Should Have a Broken-In Backup Reed
Most pipers have spare chanter reeds.
But there’s a big difference between having a spare reed and having a backup reed that’s actually ready to play.
If the reed in your pipes suddenly cracks, gets damaged, becomes unstable or simply decides it isn’t going to cooperate on the day you need it most, reaching into your pipe case and pulling out a brand-new, unplayed reed isn’t always much help.
That’s why I believe every piper should have at least one backup reed that has already been played, tested and broken in.
Your Backup Should Be a Reed You Already Trust
When you find a reed you really like, the best time to prepare its replacement isn’t after something happens to it.
It’s while that reed is still playing well.
Find another reed that works well in your chanter and spend some time playing it. Get it settled. Check the tuning. Make sure you’re comfortable with the strength and know how it behaves in your particular chanter.
You don't necessarily need to play it every day. The goal is simply to get it beyond that brand-new stage and know that if you needed to put it into your pipes tomorrow, you could confidently play it.
That's a true backup reed.
Try to Match What You Already Like
Your backup doesn't have to be absolutely identical to your primary reed, but the closer you can get, the easier the transition will be.
Think about the characteristics that matter to you:
Blowing pressure
Pitch
Balance across the scale
High G and High A
Overall tone
Stability
If you know the pressure of your current reed in inches of water (inH₂O), that gives you an especially useful starting point when preparing a backup.
Instead of simply saying, “I need another Medium,” you can look for a reed that plays at or near a pressure you already know works for you.
Don't Completely Forget About It
Once your backup reed is ready, don't put it away for a year and assume it'll be exactly the same when you need it.
Cane changes.
Every so often, take your backup out and play it. Make sure it still feels right, sounds good and works properly in your chanter.
This is particularly important as you approach competition season, a major performance or a trip where replacing a reed could be difficult.
I'd much rather discover at home that my backup needs some attention than discover it five minutes before I need to play.
How Should You Store a Backup Chanter Reed?
This part matters.
A broken-in reed needs to be protected physically, but you also need to think about its environment.
You don't want it loose in your pipe case where the blades can be damaged. You also don't want it experiencing extreme changes in humidity and temperature.
Ideally, store your backup reeds in a protective reed container with controlled humidity.
For our own reed storage, we prefer around 70-75% relative humidity. The goal is to keep the cane from repeatedly going through large swings between very dry and very humid conditions.
Humidity control doesn't mean making the reed soaking wet. You're trying to provide a stable environment.
And remember that humidity packs need to be checked and replaced when necessary. Don't put a reed in a box with a humidity pack and forget about it indefinitely.
Keep More Than One If You're Competing or Traveling
For the average recreational piper, one good backup may be enough.
If you're competing regularly, performing professionally or traveling for piping, I'd consider having more than one proven reed available.
Reeds are small. Your entire performance depends on one.
Having two or three reeds that you've already played and know will work in your chanter gives you options if conditions change or something unexpected happens.
That's particularly valuable when traveling to a different climate.
Have a spare chanter to rotate through backup reeds
If you've got a primary reed that is working beautifully, leave it alone and enjoy it.
Play the primary reed maybe 5-10 minutes every time you play to keep it ticking along.
Put the time into playing potential backup reeds and figuring out which reeds to choose to be the back up reeds.
Your backup has a different job.
It needs enough playing time to settle and enough occasional playing to confirm that it's still ready.
It doesn't need to replace a perfectly good primary reed every other practice.
Prepare Before There's a Problem
A backup reed isn't something you should start thinking about after your favorite reed stops working.
By then, it's too late.
When you find a reed you love, use that opportunity to start preparing another one. Get it broken in. Learn how it behaves. Store it properly. Check it periodically.
Then if something happens to your primary reed, you're not starting over with an unknown reed.
You're reaching for one you've already played, already tuned and already trust.
A little preparation can save a lot of frustration—especially when you've got somewhere important to play.
Your spare reed shouldn't just be a spare. It should be ready.
Comments