Sound Advice: Is Your High G Too Sharp? Don't Blame the Reed Just Yet!
If you're covering more than half of your High G hole with tape just to bring the note into tune, something isn't quite right. But before you reach for a blade to adjust your reed, there's something else you should check first.
We recently received a question from a piper experiencing a persistent tuning problem:
“We have a consistent issue with the High G on our chanters. To get that note in tune, over 50% of the hole is covered. If we pull the reed out slightly, the High A goes flat. Any solution to this persistent issue?”
It's a good question, and one that highlights an often-overlooked part of chanter reed performance: moisture.
First, Look at Your Bagpipe Setup
If this is happening with more than two or three reeds, our first thought wouldn't necessarily be that the reeds are the problem.
Instead, we'd start by looking at the moisture management system in the bagpipe.
As a piper plays, the relative humidity inside the chanter stock should eventually climb toward 90%. This moisture helps the cane maintain the characteristics it needs to vibrate properly.
However, if you're using too many drying systems in your bagpipe, you may actually be removing too much moisture from the air before it reaches the chanter reed.
The result? A reed that's being kept too dry, potentially affecting its vibration and tuning characteristics, including a sharp High G.
Before making any adjustments to the reed itself, take a look at your moisture control setup. Are you using multiple drying systems? Is the air reaching your chanter reed too dry?
Sometimes the solution is as simple as making a change to your moisture management system.

What If It Really Is the Reed?
If you've ruled out moisture issues and determined that the reed itself is the problem, there is an adjustment that may help.
An overly tight reed can sometimes produce a sharp High G because the blades aren't vibrating as freely as they should.
Before making that adjustment, it's helpful to understand the three basic sections of a chanter reed blade:
Soundbox: The lower section of the blade.
Ramp: The middle section of the blade.
Tip: The upper section of the blade.
Each section plays a role in how the reed vibrates and produces sound.
Adjusting the Ramp Section
If the reed is overly tight and producing a sharp High G, carefully removing a small amount of cane from the ramp section may help.
Using a sharp razor blade or X-Acto knife, gently scrape upward along the center of the blade, beginning at the top of the soundbox and stopping at the beginning of the tip section.
Think of it as creating a narrow stripe up the middle of the ramp.
The goal is to remove just a little mass from the blade, allowing it to vibrate more effectively.
Make a very small adjustment, then test the reed again.
If necessary, you can carefully scrape a little on either side of that center stripe as well.
The key is to work gradually. You can always remove a little more cane, but you can't put it back once it's gone.
Keep in mind that any reed adjustment can affect other notes and the overall balance of the chanter, so check the full scale as you go.
Our Advice: Don't Attack the Reed First!
When something isn't tuning correctly, it's tempting to assume the reed needs adjusting.
But in our experience, the problem is often somewhere else in the bagpipe setup.
Before reaching for a razor blade, investigate the moisture system, check the conditions reaching the chanter reed, and make sure you're addressing the actual cause.
A properly functioning reed depends on more than just the reed itself.
Good tuning starts with understanding the entire instrument.
Have a question about chanter reeds, tuning, or bagpipe setup? Send it our way. Your question might be featured in a future Sound Advice article!
Melvin Reeds — Helping Pipers Find Their Sound.



Comments